Teens and communities call for more services for families, youth
A report released today provides a detailed analysis of the experience of marginalized and street involved Aboriginal youth in B.C.
Called Moving Upstream, the report analyzes the experiences in nine B.C. communities of 410 homeless, inadequately housed, street involved and marginalized Aboriginal youth ages 12 to 18. It also includes the response to these findings from Aboriginal community members, and calls for increased services.
The report is a further analysis of a McCreary Centre Society survey conducted in late 2006 of marginalized and street involved B.C. youth that found more than half the youth (54 per cent) who participated identified as Aboriginal. This was a significant increase over a similar study in 2000.
Concerned about the increase, community members requested more information about the health of these youth. With funding provided by the Canadian Institutes for Health Research (CIHR), McCreary Centre, in partnership with UBC School of Nursing, was able to hire a team of Aboriginal researchers to analyze the findings and hold discussions with Aboriginal service providers, Elders and community members in each of the nine communities from the original study.
Community discussions suggested several possible reasons for the significant increase in Aboriginal participants between the 2000 and 2006 study, including an increase in the Aboriginal youth population, the effects of a lack of affordable housing and inadequate social assistance, and youth feeling more willing to identify as Aboriginal.
“Although the original survey was not created solely for Aboriginal youth, these findings suggest Aboriginal youth continue to experience the legacy of colonization, and the cultural disconnection that this causes,” said Annie Smith, Executive Director of the McCreary Centre, a non-profit organization concerned with the health of young people in British Columbia. “I think the report clearly shows the need to ensure there are Aboriginal-specific programs and services available to children, youth and their families in their communities.”
“The challenges Aboriginal youth face in all these communities are sobering,” said UBC Associate Professor Dr. Elizabeth Saewyc, who serves as McCreary Centre’s Research Director and was Principal Investigator of the study. “At the same time, it’s important to recognize how many of the young people we surveyed had strong hopes for their future, and were working hard to create a better life. Despite the obstacles, many were going to school, were working, were connected to their family, and reaching for healthier opportunities.”
Other key findings include:
- A large number of the youth reported leaving home before entering their teen years. Over 40 per cent had first run away at age 12 or younger, and one in three had been kicked out by age 12, underscoring the importance of early interventions with families.
- 47 per cent had gone hungry because they or their parents didn’t have money for food.
- Violence was a significant issue for most of the youth. 63 per cent reported having witnessed family violence, and almost 60 per cent having been physically abused. One in four reported experiencing racial discrimination in the past year.
- Despite the problems they face, Aboriginal youth in the worst circumstances are still doing their best to complete their education. Forty-one per cent of those who lived in squats, abandoned buildings, tents, on the street, in hotels, and in shelters were still attending school.
- Young people said their communities needed more services; the most common services needed were for safe and affordable housing, job training and work experience.
- The community discussions highlighted the importance of connecting street-involved youth with cultural and traditional teachings in order to strengthen their relationships to their cultures and communities.
According to Saewyc, both the youth and community members identified housing as a key issue. “At each of the community discussions, our research team heard about low vacancy rates, high rents, discrimination from landlords, and the lack of housing in many First Nations’ communities and on reserves,” she said.
In the report introduction, BC’s Representative for Children and Youth, Mary Ellen Turpel-Lafond wrote, “…a closer look at marginalized and street involved Aboriginal youth tells a grim story of our service delivery system failing to reach Aboriginal youth and the cracks in our civil society which challenge the most vulnerable.”
"The trauma Aboriginal people have suffered because of colonization still affects our young people today," Aboriginal researcher Brittany Bingham said. "We need to remember this when we are designing services to help them."
“Programs and services are only part of the solution,” Aboriginal researcher Dana Brunanski added. “We need societal change and community-level healing, in order to create a world where more of our youth can choose a good path.”
“These findings are important to help us plan public health services in urban settings across Canada,” said Dr. Nancy Edwards, Scientific Director of the CIHR’s Institute of Population and Public Health. “They highlight the role that social determinants such as education, income and housing play in defining the difficult choices marginalized youth face and remind us of the importance of public health services that are tailored to vulnerable population subgroups.”
“I congratulate Dr. Saewyc on her work with Aboriginal youth,” said Dr. Malcolm King, the new Scientific Director of CIHR’s Institute of Aboriginal People’s Health. “While I agree fully with her assessment of the great challenges Aboriginal youth face, I am heartened to see that more of them express pride in their heritage and seek assistance from Aboriginal centres.”
Research team members are available for interviews:
- Dr. Elizabeth Saewyc, Principal Investigator
- Annie Smith, Executive Director, McCreary Centre Society
The full report is available for free download as a pdf at www.mcs.bc.ca.
The McCreary Centre Society is a non-profit organisation committed to improving the health of BC youth through community based projects and youth engagement and leadership projects which address current youth health issues.
The Stigma and Resilience Among Vulnerable Youth Consortium (SARAVYC) of the UBC School of Nursing, led by Dr. Elizabeth Saewyc, was a partner in this research. Funding for SARAVYC and this study was provided by CIHR’s Institute of Population and Public Health and CIHR’s Institute of Gender and Health. Dr. Saewyc also holds a Chair in Public Health supported by CIHR and the Public Health Agency of Canada.
The Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR) is the Government of Canada’s agency for health research. CIHR’s mission is to create new scientific knowledge and to enable its translation into improved health, more effective health services and products, and a strengthened Canadian health care system. Composed of 13 Institutes, CIHR provides leadership and support to nearly 12,000 health researchers and trainees across Canada. www.cihr-irsc.gc.ca
Moving Upstream Backgrounder
The McCreary Centre Society’s original study was entitled Against the Odds: A profile of marginalised and street involved youth in BC. (Report also available at www.mcs.bc.ca)
The survey was administered in late 2006 to young people involved in a street lifestyle, including those who were homeless, panhandling, involved in the sex trade, selling or using drugs, engaging in criminal activities, or who had recently left these situations.
The survey was a pencil and paper questionnaire based on previous McCreary youth health surveys, with additional input from an advisory committee of representatives from Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal youth-serving organizations from nine communities across B.C. Communities that participated in the study were Abbotsford and Mission, Kamloops, Kelowna, Nanaimo, Prince George, Prince Rupert, Surrey, Vancouver and Victoria.
More than half of the 762 youth who completed the survey indicated Aboriginal identity (54 per cent). In contrast, only 10 per cent of youth in B.C. schools are Aboriginal (Ministry of Education, 2007).
Among the 410 Aboriginal youth in the survey, the majority reported First Nations status (59 per cent), while another one in four said they were Aboriginal without status (26 per cent), 11 per cent were Métis, and one per cent were Inuit. The rest either indicated Indigenous ancestry from outside of Canada, or did not provide specific information about their Aboriginal ancestry.
Youth between the ages of 12 and 18 completed the survey. The average age was 16 years old. 48 per cent were male, 51 per cent were female, and one per cent were transgender or did not provide this information.
Street involved and marginalized Aboriginal youth reported a number of challenges that can affect their health long-term. Among these:
- 42% of those who participated in the survey had been in foster care.
- Lesbian, gay, and bisexual youth (LGB) were highly over-represented, especially among female participants.
- 30% of males and 23% of females had been sexually exploited. Youth who reported physical or sexual abuse were twice as likely to be sexually exploited as those who were not abused.
- 1 in 3 youth had been pregnant or had caused a pregnancy.
- Consistent with other street involved youth, Aboriginal youth were likely to report a family history of substance use, as well as to use drugs or alcohol themselves.
- 30% of females and 18% of males had attempted suicide at least once during the past year.
– 30 –